Shiloh Hendrix's First Amendment fiasco
After reading Symone Harms' article for Alpha News, I'm left questioning Minnesota prosecutors' constitutional understanding and their vindictiveness. Harms wrote about a prosecution of Shiloh Hendrix. According to Harms' srticle, "According to a fact sheet released by her new legal team, Hendrix was at a playground with her young son when she saw a boy going through her diaper bag and believed he could be taking her belongings. During the encounter, Hendrix used a racial slur. The defense says an adult bystander, Sharmake Beyle Omar, then approached Hendrix, recorded her, and repeatedly urged her to repeat the slur as she attempted to leave. A recording of the encounter went viral."
I'm not defending Hendrix's slur, especially since it doesn't say what it was. Still, racial slurs aren't considered threatening or inciting speech. If Hendrix is guilty of using vulgar language only, we couldn't build enough jails and prisons to hold all the 'criminals.'
Further, hate speech is protected speech. Hopefully, this brings a little clarity to the subject:
We don't need the First Amendment to protect noncontroversial speech. It's there to protect controversial, outrageous but not inciteful speech. The minute this reaches the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals, it's history. It's that simple.
Comments
Post a Comment